--- title: Multifamily Lenders in Erie County, NY: 36 Made Loans in 2024-25 url: https://lender.report/lenders-in/new-york/erie-county/ license: https://lender.report/license/ --- County ยท NY # Multifamily lenders in Erie County, NY 36 lenders made 207 multifamily loans in Erie County, NY in 2024 and 2025, $887.5M in all. Tompkins Bank & Trust made the most, with 30. The typical loan was about $1.1M. The county is part of the Buffalo, NY metro area. **Evidence** Multifamily loans placed in the county, HMDA **Data as of** HMDA 2025 **Page last changed** November 11, 2026 **Lenders on record** 36 HMDA, 2025 **Multifamily loans, 2024-25** 207 HMDA, 2025 Manufactured-home parks excluded **Dollars** $887M HMDA, 2025 **Typical loan** $1.1M HMDA, 2025 Cite this Source: The Lender Report, Multifamily lenders in Erie County, NY, https://lender.report/lenders-in/new-york/erie-county/, data as of December 31, 2025. ## Describe a deal in Erie County, NY See which of these lenders made loans like yours, at your size and in your place. No account and no form. [Show multifamily loans in Erie County, NY](https://lender.report/comps/?lane=multifamily&state=NY&county=36029)[On this list? Find your page](https://lender.report/for-lenders/?from=market) | Lender | Kind | Based in | Loans | Dollars | 2025 loans | 2024 loans | Typical loan | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | [Tompkins Bank & Trust](https://lender.report/lender/tompkins-bank-and-trust-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/tompkins-bank-and-trust-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Ithaca, NY | 30 | $118M | 18 | 12 | $760K | | [Lake Shore Bank](https://lender.report/lender/lake-shore-bank-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/lake-shore-bank-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Dunkirk, NY | 22 | $27.5M | 11 | 11 | $1M | | [Five Star Bank](https://lender.report/lender/five-star-bank-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/five-star-bank-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Rochester, NY | 21 | $98.8M | 12 | 9 | $1.7M | | [Nextier Bank, National Association](https://lender.report/lender/nextier-bank-pa/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/nextier-bank-pa/multifamily/) | Bank | Kittanning, PA | 17 | $58.2M | 14 | 3 | $1.6M | | [Alden State Bank](https://lender.report/lender/alden-state-bank-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/alden-state-bank-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Alden, NY | 12 | $14.9M | 9 | 3 | $920K | | [Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company](https://lender.report/lender/manufacturers-and-traders-trust-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/manufacturers-and-traders-trust-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Buffalo, NY | 9 | $11.5M | 8 | 1 | $900K | | [CNB Bank](https://lender.report/lender/cnb-bank-pa/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/cnb-bank-pa/multifamily/) | Bank | Clearfield, PA | 8 | $36.8M | 4 | 4 | $3.5M | | [Broadview Credit Union](https://lender.report/lender/broadview-credit-union-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/broadview-credit-union-ny/multifamily/) | Credit union | Albany, NY | 8 | $33.1M | 6 | 2 | $3.1M | | [Bank of Holland](https://lender.report/lender/bank-of-holland-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/bank-of-holland-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Holland, NY | 5 | $5.36M | 1 | 4 | $700K | | [Community Bank, National Association](https://lender.report/lender/community-bank-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/community-bank-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Canton, NY | 5 | $2.54M | 2 | 3 | $460K | | [Walker & Dunlop, LLC](https://lender.report/lender/walker-and-dunlop-md/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/walker-and-dunlop-md/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Bethesda, MD | 4 | $71.0M | 3 | 1 | $21M | | [Chemung Canal Trust Company, National Association](https://lender.report/lender/chemung-canal-trust-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/chemung-canal-trust-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Elmira, NY | 4 | $15.9M | 3 | 1 | $2.2M | | [Empower Credit Union](https://lender.report/lender/empower-credit-union-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/empower-credit-union-ny/multifamily/) | Credit union | Syracuse, NY | 4 | $13.3M | 1 | 3 | $3.6M | | [Velocity Commercial Capital LLC](https://lender.report/lender/velocity-commercial-capital-ca/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/velocity-commercial-capital-ca/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Westlake Village, CA | 4 | $1.24M | 2 | 2 | $340K | | [M&T Realty Capital Corporation](https://lender.report/lender/m-and-t-realty-capital-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/m-and-t-realty-capital-ny/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Buffalo, NY | 3 | $28.0M | 1 | 2 | $6M | | [Wells Fargo Bank, National Association](https://lender.report/lender/wells-fargo-bank-sd/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/wells-fargo-bank-sd/multifamily/) | Bank | Sioux Falls, SD | 3 | $21.0M | 3 | 0 | $6.3M | | [NBT Bank, National Association](https://lender.report/lender/nbt-bank-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/nbt-bank-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Norwich, NY | 3 | $4.78M | 3 | 0 | $840K | | [Cattaraugus County Bank](https://lender.report/lender/cattaraugus-county-bank-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/cattaraugus-county-bank-ny/multifamily/) | Bank | Little Valley, NY | 3 | $2.38M | 3 | 0 | $660K | | [BPL Mortgage, LLC](https://lender.report/lender/bpl-mortgage-il/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/bpl-mortgage-il/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Oakbrook Terrace, IL | 3 | $1.36M | 1 | 2 | $380K | | [Arbor Realty Trust, Inc.](https://lender.report/lender/arbor-realty-trust-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/arbor-realty-trust-ny/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Uniondale, NY | 2 | $87.0M | 2 | 0 | $62M | | [NewPoint Real Estate Capital](https://lender.report/lender/newpoint-real-estate-capital-tx/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/newpoint-real-estate-capital-tx/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Plano, TX | 2 | $53.0M | 1 | 1 | $33M | | [Greystone Servicing Corporation, Inc.](https://lender.report/lender/greystone-servicing-tn-memphis-kqgfmz98/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/greystone-servicing-tn-memphis-kqgfmz98/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Memphis, TN | 2 | $42.8M | 0 | 2 | $34M | | [Northwest Bank](https://lender.report/lender/northwest-bank-pa/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/northwest-bank-pa/multifamily/) | Savings | Warren, PA | 2 | $11.2M | 0 | 2 | $11M | | [Americu Credit Union](https://lender.report/lender/americu-credit-union-ny/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/americu-credit-union-ny/multifamily/) | Credit union | Rome, NY | 2 | $1.16M | 0 | 2 | $620K | | [Constructive Loans LLC](https://lender.report/lender/constructive-loans-il/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/constructive-loans-il/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Oakbrook Terrace, IL | 2 | $540K | 2 | 0 | $280K | | [A&D Mortgage LLC](https://lender.report/lender/a-and-d-mortgage-fl/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/a-and-d-mortgage-fl/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Ft. Lauderdale, FL | 2 | $480K | 2 | 0 | $320K | | [Merchants Bank of Indiana](https://lender.report/lender/merchants-bank-of-indiana-in/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/merchants-bank-of-indiana-in/multifamily/) | Bank | Carmel, IN | 1 | $14.0M | 1 | 0 | $14M | | [KeyBank National Association](https://lender.report/lender/keybank-oh/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/keybank-oh/multifamily/) | Bank | Cleveland, OH | 1 | $11.0M | 0 | 1 | $11M | | [LendingOne LLC](https://lender.report/lender/lendingone-fl/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/lendingone-fl/multifamily/) | Non-bank | Boca Raton, FL | 1 | $2.10M | 1 | 0 | $2.1M | | [Union Savings Bank](https://lender.report/lender/union-savings-bank-ct/) [multifamily record](https://lender.report/lender/union-savings-bank-ct/multifamily/) | Savings | Danbury, CT | 1 | $1.80M | 1 | 0 | $1.8M | HMDA, 2025 [Check a deal in Erie County, NY in Loan Comps](https://lender.report/comps/?lane=multifamily&state=NY&county=36029) | Loan size | Loans | Lenders | | --- | --- | --- | | Under $1M | 97 | 24 | | $1M to $2.5M | 39 | 13 | | $2.5M to $5M | 27 | 12 | | $5M to $10M | 14 | 7 | | $10M or more | 30 | 14 | HMDA, 2025 - Lenders made 207 multifamily loans totaling $887.5M in Erie County, NY in 2024 and 2025. HMDA, 2025 - 15 of these loans were made by lenders that have since merged or closed. They are counted in the totals here and appear in no lender's row. HMDA, 2025 - 120 of the loans were made in 2025 and 87 in 2024. HMDA, 2025 - The typical loan in Erie County, NY was about $1.1M, with the middle half between $540K and $4M. HMDA, 2025 - 97 of the loans were under $1M, and 44 were $5M or more. HMDA, 2025 - Lenders reported a median rate of 6.86% on 150 loans in Erie County, NY, with the middle half between 6.45% and 7.50%. HMDA, 2025 - The median term was 10 years. HMDA, 2025 - The median loan to value was 70%. HMDA, 2025 - 42% of the loans were refinancings and 54% were purchases. HMDA, 2025 - Banks and savings institutions made 147 of the loans, credit unions 14, and non-banks 31. HMDA, 2025 - The five most active lenders made 49.3% of the loans. HMDA, 2025 - The three most active lenders were Tompkins Bank & Trust with 30, Lake Shore Bank with 22, and Five Star Bank with 21. HMDA, 2025 - 16 of the 36 lenders are based in New York. The rest are based elsewhere, most often in Pennsylvania, California and Connecticut. HMDA, 2025 - The most common property size was 5 to 24 units, with 134 loans. HMDA, 2025 - Erie County, NY is part of the Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY metro area, which has its own page. OMB metro list, 2025 ## How this list is defined **Measure** Multifamily loans made in Erie County, NY **Period** 2024 and 2025 **Formula** Count, by lender, of HMDA records for multifamily dwellings of 5 or more units placed in the county, manufactured-home parks excluded, for each year in which the public file holds 5 or more such loans in the county. **Order** Largest first by loans recorded in the place, then dollars, then name. Payment is not part of the order. **As of** 2025 **Source** [HMDA](https://ffiec.cfpb.gov/data-browser/) **Changelog** November 12, 2026: First published, with the data built on this date. ## What we don't know - Whether any of these lenders is taking new loans today. - What they charge or require beyond the rate and term that HMDA reports. - Loans on office, retail, industrial or hotel property. HMDA covers dwelling-secured loans only. A metro area or county is named for a year only when the public file holds 5 or more multifamily loans there that year, so a small place is never exposed by a count. SBA loans are on record by state only, so this page has no SBA figures for the county. The state pages carry them. HMDA covers dwelling-secured loans. Amounts are the midpoints of $10,000 bands, and each loan has a year, never a date. Lenders that merged or stopped filing are left out. Source and date appear beside each figure. Banks report balances, not loans made. Loans made come only from HMDA and SBA files. We do not audit filings and can make errors joining them. [Report a problem](https://lender.report/report/) Figures come from public records and show the source and date beside them. Public records can be late, incomplete or wrong. A past loan does not mean a lender will make the same kind of loan today. Confirm anything important with the lender.